End Of Season Reviews: Patrick Kane, Part II — Now Let’s Talk Hockey
Breaking down Patrick Kane’s season by looking at his end-of-year totals is impossible. All you see is the fact that his goals, assists, and points were all down against the last 2 years. The story of the boy’s season is much more intricate, and it all started last summer when a certain Blackhawks executive who shall remain nameless (but whose name rhymes with “Dan Showman”) decided to cover up his inability to obtain a second-line center, and in the process throw a wrench into Kane’s season.
In short, Kane was put in a position to fail, and I don’t hold him responsible for his statistical slump. It’s most demonstrably the fault of the guy who has never played a single minute of time in the NHL.
In mid- to late-summer of 2011, Kane was approached with the idea of moving to center on the second line. This had been tried before back in the pre-season of 2008, when Kane played one period at the pivot — a move that contributed to the Blackhawks allowing lowly Minnesota to race to a 3-0 first period lead. That was the end of that. But yet, here it was, rearing its ugly head again. It was soon apparent that no measure of haranguing by the media or the fans was going to prevent this from happening, so everyone decided to put a happy face on it and wait to see what happened.
Optimism reigned as the season got underway: Kaner notched 2 goals and 4 assists in his first 4 contests, with a cumulative +3 rating. Additionally, the area where it was expected that Kane would flounder embarrassingly turned out to be one of his strengths: Kane won 2/3 of his face-offs in game 1, and nearly 3/4 of them in game 3! Things were looking pretty good, and both the fans and the media were ready to take the dunce cap off of the guy who conceived of this scheme.
Then somebody noticed: where are the goals? Kane soon fell into some troublesome goal slumps: 6 games, then 4 games, then 8 games without a tally. He was throwing some helpers in there, but his face-off percentage was dropping to the levels everyone expected at the outset, and his defensive lapses were beginning to cost the team goals. He was ending the majority of his games either flat or in the minus column, and it began to look like this wasn’t such a good idea anymore.
Blackhawks Head Coach Joel Quenneville agreed. Kane was moved back to the wing, and soon youngster Marcus Kruger was given the job of centering the 2nd line. Lo and behold, Marian Hossa went on an 8-game point streak starting almost immediately after Kruger was put at the pivot. Unfortunately, the move did not improve Kane’s game one bit: the goal slumps continued, as did his negative-column appearances. He was tried again at center for a four-game stretch spanning the New Year, with equally calamitous results. Kaner was moved back to the wing, where he stayed from January 6 to the end of February.
But then, once again, there he was back playing center! He stayed there for the final 18 games of the season, notching a middling 9 goals and 5 assists, tallying a cumulative minus-4 in that stretch. Doubtless this was a last-ditch effort by a certain Blackhawks executive who shall remain nameless to try to justify a bad decision.
What it did instead was put an exclamation point on a lousy year for Patrick Kane. It showed that he did not have the ability to play the center position well, and it also showed that it messed up the boy’s mind enough that it affected his play on the wing also. Kane finished with 66 points in 82 games, his worst season since turning pro.
Do I blame him? Not one bit. That performance is the fault of a certain Blackhawks executive who shall remain nameless. Kane actually did more than a respectable job playing a position he was unfamiliar with, and he endured this foolishness with a fair bit of class.
The Blackhawks have tried to do this for years: take a player who has spent his entire career playing one way, and try to make him play a different way. They ruined nearly every draft pick they brought to their AHL affiliates during the 90′s, resulting in teams that had no idea whether they were coming or going half the time.
There are very few players, even at the NHL level, who can re-train themselves and adapt to a new position successfully. We have found out the hard way that Patrick Kane is not one of them. Taking a craftsman like Kane and asking him to change a mind-set that he has turned into an art form over 15+ years of honing his skills is butt-stupid in two ways: it puts an ill-equipped and badly-trained player at a position he is unfamiliar with; AND it leaves a hole at that player’s previous position that is necessarily going to be filled by somebody with inferior skill.
Nope, this experiment was a terrible mistake, it ruined Kane’s season, and Quenneville has stated behind the scenes that this kind of “meddling” on the part of a certain Blackhawks executive who shall remain nameless is not going to be tolerated anymore. With luck, that means we will see Patrick Kane back on the wing where he belongs, chewing his mouthguard like an 8-year-old and putting the moves on defensemen and goaltenders like they were cardboard cut-outs.
I am looking forward to seeing Patrick Kane back on the wing next season. Hopefully we will see him back at the point-per-game level again like we all know he can be.
Follow Cheer The Anthem on Twitter @CheerTheAnthem and on Facebook
If you’re on your iPhone, save cheertheanthem.noticeorange.com to your bookmarks. Works like an app.
| Print article | This entry was posted by Tim Currell on June 11, 2012 at 6:31 am, and is filed under 2011-12 Player Evaluations, 2012 Off-Season, Blackhawks, Chicago Blackhawks. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
Kane played his whole life as a center and made the switch just before he entered the NHL. Problem with this move is that the next best RW capable player after Hoss is Shaw who also a natural Center. Shaw may be a amazing or he may have had the Rookie bump because he wasn't considered a priority by the opposing team.
Its not the right side where the Hawks have issues, its the left. As Sharp actually spent a lot of time this season playing the right wing (even though he is more naturally a left wing) Also Shaw saw tough quality of competition, playing with Bolland (and who cares if he is a "natural" center, it's way easier to make the move from center to wing than vice versa)
While the move to center is certainly a difficult adjustment, especially for a player who cut his teeth in the NHL at the wing position, I would not go so far as to say that Kane was put in a position to fail. Rather, exactly the opposite, Kane was given every opportunity to succeed in his new role. In fact, the only Blackhawk who received a higher percentage of his zone starts in the offensive zone was Brandon Bollig, easily the most sheltered of the Hawks players. Meanwhile, players who we would think of as being considerably more sheltered than Kane (or perhaps as players who should be more sheltered than Kane) like Marcus Kruger, Andrew Shaw, Michael Frolik, and Brian Bickell all had considerably tougher sledding (as Kruger took on the secondary shutdown role after Bolland, and Bickell, Frolik, and Shaw all took on tough checking line assignments). Also, Toews faced considerably tougher competition, when he was heatlhy. Meaning, that, when Toews was healthy, Kane was getting lots of O-zone starts against opponents secondary skaters. That seems like it should be a recipe for success for a guy with Kane's offensive talents, doesn't it? Regardless of whether he was a center or a wing. Actually Kane's late season points surge came when Toews was hurt, and could no longer shoulder the minutes against tougher checking opponents, which raises big questions about earlier in the season. Was it an adjustment to playing center? Maybe. Was it just plain bad luck? Also, maybe, Kane was still one of the Hawks best CORSI Relative players (although Viktor Stalberg was better CORSI relative despite facing slightly tougher opposition) Does this suggest Kane needs to stay on the right wing. Probably But, does this excuse Kane from any blame for what was, easily, his most disappointing season to date in his (still very young!) Blackhawks career? HELL NO. Now, that doesn't mean he should be traded, or that he's lazy, or doesn't care, blah, blah, blah. I don't buy any of that stuff. What it does mean, is that he hasn't done much in 2011-2012 to ingratiate himself with the coaches, the front office, or his teammates and had better correct that in 2012-2013.
In addition to that, I'll just say that: there are quite a lot of stats to suggest that Kane is capable of being (or even should be) a successful second line center on the Blackhawks. The defensive shortcomings are what they are, but Kane is utilized in such a fashion (most of his non-neutral ice starts are O-zone starts, very rarely does he take a draw in the defensive zone) that is meant to maximize his offensive prowess (If he could win or draw, or even learn to win a draw, then there would be a strong argument to be made that then Kane should be a center). When Kane is on the ice the Hawks generally dictate puck possession, the only Hawks with Better Corsi Rel. in 2011-2012 were Jonathan Toews, Viktor Stalberg (oddly enough), and Patrick Sharp, who faced considerably weaker competition, Sharp's 2011-2012 Corsi Rel. QoC was suprisingly low, despite his reputation as a penalty killer and two-way player). So, since Kane often controls the puck in the offensive zone, his successes in puck possession show that he ought to succeed at scoring as well, even at the center possession. His likely hood of success only goes up, also, with a healthy Jonathan Toews, who crushes competition despite difficult matchups, and would drive down Kanes' CORSI Rel. QoC, which, one would think, would lead to more scoring opportunities, a better +/-, etc., etc., etc.
Last one. I keep thinking of things after I hit the post button. The absolute futility of the Power Play (a unit, on which Kane often played wing) was absolutely brutal. It, at least in part, contributed to Kane's poor over all numbers (fewest PP goals and points yet in his career). Conversely Kane shares culpability for the poorness of the PP.





Exciting…
[...]I just found a fantastic way to save costs while opening a company overseas[...]…
The Absent Game…
Between me and my husband we have owned a lot more MP3 players through the years than I can count, which includes Sansas, iRivers, iPods (classic & touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few decades I’ve settled down to one line of gamers….
Thorn of Girl…
Excellent information is usually uncovered on this website website….
case, you can get the help you…
need easily.you can also add plugins to your blog if needed. it is easy to edit a blog template and make it look the way you want it to. make a daily schedule for your blog to keep updated. is is…
take you seriously. so yes, you need…
both.what are some of the top reasons writers fail at this? what would you say are the top areas most people go wrong?the number one reason, besides procrastination, is not learning about marketing. many writers think that books will just market…
wondered why children and grown-ups alike are…
attracted to picture books or websites that have eye-catching images? this is because most people tend to associate a lot of meaning to pictures.when used appropriately, a picture can enhance what you write and convey a lot of meaning to the…
posts.optimize your blog- it is very vital…
for a blog to be optimized for the sake of your users, the search engines, and income. you must have a clean site and a white background really works well. for seo bloggermarketing, try to change your permalinks to this option:…
if you sort the results by date…
and size you can identify any trends.another alternative is to subscribe to publishing trade magazines. or look them up in your public library. these magazines list all new publications. the number of pages and format is often also included. so ensurin…
short as possible. the ideal number for…
a blog post is 300-400 words. avoid writing lengthy posts, people don’t have much time and cannot read your posts all day. instead, try to use some pictures. this way you can make your blog look more attractive.be consistentif you wish…
a clearer picture.5) use of keywords -…
though keywords are important remember not to overdo them. to put a clearer picture in front of the reader keywords should always be sprinkled over your content rather than “stuffed”!!6) headline – don’t be afraid to be creative with your headlines…
have finished. a blog with loads of…
spelling mistakes and grammar issues will not get loads of people returning, a spell checked blog looks and fells more professional and will get more people coming back. depending on what website you are using to blog on it should have…
best methods to earn money on the…
internet is to build an e-mail list.internet marketers will pay you to write messages that may be placed in their auto responder. these only need to be a couple hundred words to be effective so you can expect to make about…
a paper handy so that you can…
note down the important points about that topic which you would like to cover in your post.after noting down the important points read as much as you can about them so that you have a clear understanding of each point, and…
do it it will have pros and…
cons. the pros are that you get a cool symbol and each time you prestige the symbol is different then the last and you also get more options for challenges. the cons are that you start all over with pretty much…
what i am trying to do, which…
is to help you create some income so that it can sustain you until the bigger money comes in.so anyway, the go to the search box for the search engine of your choice and put in “kindle publishing for blogs”. find…
mind. people find it easier to read…
dark type against a light background, the other way around and it’s extremely tiring for the eyes.your blog should be attractive and allow visitors to navigate to other content easily. if it takes too long to find other articles or content…
the same thing-they are inseparable.the author i…
spoke to only had a few chapters of her book written, and she was struggling to move forward with it. she didn’t want to talk to me about “marketing” so as i continued to try to help her, i avoided using…
content which is targeted and designed to…
provide useful and beneficial information to your readers. this is the very first habit that you must develop to become a successful blogger. failure is the beginning of success: – it doesn’t matter if you failed in your first blogging attempt….
not all of these courses do this,…
as some teachers require little writing or focus too much on reading. these courses should only teach writing – how to write essays, research papers, create effective arguments, and so on.students in this era have learned to transmit messages in the…
salary because of the risks (hazardous duty)….
an employer does not want to send someone who doesn’t understand the risks. late-career people are much less risky hires in this respect. the major overseas contractors are basically structured like the us military so many of the positions will have…
this is where article writers come into…
the picture.article writers are a key element to adequate and effective seo work. knowing that you have dedicated writers pumping out your content in a reliable format in a reasonable amount of time gives you the time you need to create…
more importance, it is this: write original…
posts. i would not really call it illegal, but in the world of blog, duplicating content is as close to the dark side as you can get. that does not mean that you can not write something from another blog in…
a better idea for building my brand,…
and my business?in this article we are going to take a quick look at what i believe is the very best blog marketing strategy for newbies and work at home entrepreneurs, and i’m also going to share with you what i…
write and convey a lot of meaning…
to the reader. in other words, your blog post will appear more interesting to readers if it is supported by good images.statistical facts give credibilitywhen you are writing about any topic, you can make a lot of value addition to it…
submit articles, submit free article pro blogging…
is the method that many people are using to make incomes from home. blogging is a fairly new model that allows people to correspond with others basically for happiness or if you are a skilled blogger like me, as a way…